
Outsourcing disciplinaries and grievances
Published Nov 16, 2026
Contents
When to use an external HR investigator
Who makes the final decision
What the Fargro judgment means for employers
Speak to SSG about an independent HR investigation
Employers can bring in an external HR consultant to investigate a disciplinary issue or grievance, chair a hearing or support an appeal. This can help when a senior manager is involved, a complaint raises whistleblowing concerns, or there are too few people internally who can act impartially.
When to use an external HR investigator
Consider external support when the people who would normally investigate or hear the case have already been involved. At SSG, we have supported employers in situations such as these.
An employee raised a grievance about how managers had treated them during an ill-health capability review. The complaint also named the managing director.
A dispute between relatives working in a family business escalated to the point where the board was considering disciplinary action.
An employee affected by redundancies appealed and alleged favouritism. SSG was asked to hear the appeal.
Depending on what you need, we can investigate the facts, hold meetings and make recommendations.
In the past, we have been able to support our clients in scenarios such as:
An employee undergoing an ill-health capability review had already undergone several meetings with different members of the leadership team.
He then logged a grievance, relating to the treatment he was receiving from his manager(s). The Grievance also mentioned the MD as being the driving force behind the decision-making during the capability process.A family business found itself in a complex combination of interpersonal differences, family fall-outs and behavioural issues that escalated to a point at which disciplinary action was being considered. One of the family members and her husband had a very public argument with other members of the organisation, who were also relatives.
The board of directors was at a loss over who was to blame for what and how the organisation could move forward.A large organisation was under a retainer contract with a solicitor, receiving advice on a large restructure project.
Following the restructures / redundancies, we were asked to hear an appeal by one of the affected individuals, accusing the organisation of nepotism.
We were able to provide support on all of the above by investigating the incidents, holding the appropriate meetings and giving recommendations.
Who makes the final decision?
When SSG provides this support, the employer makes and implements the final decision. Agree the consultant’s remit before work starts and identify who will decide the outcome and who will handle any appeal. Give the employee a fair chance to respond, and make sure the decision-maker reviews the evidence and the employee’s account before reaching and recording their own conclusion.
For disciplinary cases, separate the investigation and hearing where practicable. Handle appeals impartially and, wherever possible, appoint someone who has not previously been involved. Follow your own procedure and the Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures.
What the Fargro judgement means for employers
In Fargro Ltd v Mr David Hide [2026] EAT 162, external consultants investigated and conducted the disciplinary and appeal hearings. The same manager decided to dismiss the employee and reject his appeal. The Employment Tribunal found the dismissal unfair because the same person made both decisions.
The Employment Appeal Tribunal held that the original tribunal was entitled to find that using consultants was fair in itself. It sent issues back for further consideration, including whether the employee had a proper opportunity to explain his case to the decision-maker.
Speak to SSG about an independent HR investigation
If you need help investigating a grievance, managing a disciplinary hearing or handling an appeal, speak to our HR and employment law team about the support you need.